Have you been limited to court fees only, in accordance with the sanctions of CPR 3.14 (failure to file a costs budget)? The costs thereafter of taking the matter to trial no longer look viable, but what if Part 36 could help you turn the tables and put risk back at the feet of your opponent?
We are all aware of the benefits of a good Part 36 offer as a claimant. If you make a strong offer that is not accepted within the relevant period, and you go on to secure judgment that is as beneficial as, or better than, your own offer, then you will ordinarily secure an award of costs on the indemnity basis (CPR 36.17(4)), in addition to a 10% uplift on the award made, and interest not exceeding 10% above base rate.
Indemnity costs awards are a fantastic tool; they don’t suddenly mean a windfall or free-for-all on costs recovery (as such costs still need to be assessed), but the test which the court applies when assessing indemnity basis costs is more stringent in its approach to the paying party than a standard basis assessment. The approaches are set out below:
Standard Basis approach (CPR 44.3(2))
The court will only allow costs which are proportionate to the matters in issue (even if they were reasonably or necessarily incurred); and will resolve any doubt which it may have in this regard in favour of the paying party.
Indemnity Basis approach (CPR 44.3(3))
The court will resolve any doubt which it may have (as to whether costs were reasonably incurred or were reasonable in amount) in favour of the receiving party.
An assessment on the indemnity basis shifts the assessor’s approach to being much more receiving-party friendly.
However, how does this help when you’ve been made subject to the sanctions of CPR 3.14, where you’ve been refused relief from sanctions, meaning you are limited to court fees only?
Firstly, it is worth noting that the sanctions of CPR 3.14 apply only to costs-managed costs, not to incurred (pre-budget) costs.
Secondly, if you have made a strong Part 36 offer that is later accepted outside the relevant time period, or you achieve a determination at trial equal to or better than the amount of the Part 36 offer, then CPR 36.21 is your saviour.
CPR 36.21 is often a quietly overlooked part of the CPR, but it is mighty. It applies “in any case where the offeror is treated as having filed a costs budget limited to applicable court fees”, or is otherwise limited in their recovery of costs to such fees. It allows costs which were subject to the sanctions under CPR 3.14 to be assessed in the normal way, and they are then payable by the offeree (at 50% of the total amount assessed).
Suddenly, with the assistance of a strong Part 36 offer made early on, you are back in the driving seat and have the potential to recover a large proportion of the costs you thought you had lost.
Do you have a case where you have an indemnity costs award on a costs-managed case, and/or do you want to know whether you can recover more than the awards made at costs management? Or have you been subject to the sanctions of CPR 3.14?
As advocates for access to justice, we know the importance of looking for workarounds and maximising costs recovery in these sorts of scenarios, to ensure you can carry on doing what you do best. Contact Charlene Turner or one of our Litigation Team members, who can talk you through any queries you may have in this regard.
.webp)

