One of the biggest decisions to impact professional deputies for property and finances in recent years was that of HHJ Hilder in Lumb v NHS Humber & North Yorkshire ICB [2024]. At the heart of the case was the issue of whether the management of Direct Payments or other local authority funding for care packages fell within the general authority of a deputy for property and finances.
The decision held was that it did not fall within the general authority of a deputy for property and finances because there was such an overlap with health and welfare coupled with the wording of relevant regulations governing the management of funding.
This decision had a big impact on professional deputies who can spend a significant amount of time managing Direct Payments to ensure that the Protected Parties own assets are not depleted in respect of expensive care packages. The costs involved can quickly add up and a range of figures were provided by the 7 Applicants from £1,200 up to £13,200 per year to manage P’s care package and the associated Direct Payments/local authority funding.
As a result, 7 Applications were made to the Court of Protection to seek a number of determinations regarding the management of Direct Payments.
The overall conclusion reached was that the original decision was upheld and that the management of Direct Payments cannot be considered to fall within the ‘general’ authority of a professional deputy for property and finances. HHJ Hilder found that there was input which was required to give effect to the ‘choice agenda’ which could not mean that the management of direct payments was purely ‘operational’ as contended by the applicant deputies. This reflects the original decision reached in Lumb and that the authority to manage Direct Payments is mixed and involved both property and affairs and health and welfare.
However, some important clarifications were provided:
- The Court of Protection can give a deputy authorisation as P’s deputy to manage Direct Payments, on the basis that the beneficiary of the direct payments is over 16 (in accordance with the decision in SBB).
- The requesting of Direct Payments from the statutory body and making arrangements for the Direct Payments to be paid does not fall with the general authority.
- Negotiating with the statutory body concerning the Direct Payments sufficiency does not fall within the general authority.
- The actual use and management of Direct Payments once received does not fall within the general authority.
- The preparation of employment contracts for directly employed carers does fall within the general authority.
- Retrospective approval of costs associated with managing Direct Payment can be obtained and a Deputy should make an Application to the Court to obtain specific authority to manage Direct Payments moving forward. A detailed draft Schedule of a proposed Order is provided within the Judgment and would be highly recommended to be adopted.
- The SCCO have provided guidance in respect of bills awaiting provisional assessment which cover the period after 11 October 2024 and include costs relating to managing direct payments. It is recommended that the Deputy should email the SCCO providing the details of the bill along with details confirming that the bill contains costs relating to direct payments and that an application is being made to the Court to obtain authority to manage Direct Payments. The SCCO will then pause the assessment until the Application has been determined. However, the SCCO has confirmed that once the Order granting authority has been received the assessment process will recommence and the bill will retain its place within the assessment queue.
- Retrospective approval need not be sought for steps taken and costs incurred by a Deputy managing Direct Payments for any period prior to 11 October 2024. The SCCO have subsequently provided guidance and confirmed that any bills awaiting provisional assessment where the entirety of the bill period falls before 11 October 2024 then the bill will be assessed in the normal way.
- Currently appointed Deputies can consider whether to make an Application to recover costs incurred by former Deputies in managing Direct Payments, if it is in P’s best interests.
- The judgment also included detailed guidance on the information and evidence which should be required when making an Application to the Court for authority to manage direct payments. This included:
- Setting out a succinct description of P’s current situation regarding the care needs and any care plans provided by the local authority.
- Details of the current care arrangements including how and by whom it is delivered.
- Details of the current care arrangements.
- Details of the size and nature of P’s estate.
- Details of the apportionment between private and public funding required for P’s care package.
- Details of the Deputy’s costs overall of managing P’s property and finances, alongside details of the costs (or likely costs) of managing P’s care package and direct payments.
- Details of why it is in P’s best interests for the Deputy to manage the direct payments and whether there are any realistic alternatives to the Deputy who could manage P’s direct payments.
If you have any questions or queries in respect of the recovery of costs in respect of direct payments then please feel free to get in touch.
.webp)
.webp)
